Questions on Pragmatism and The Will to Believe
William O'Meara (c) Copyright, 1997
Answer the following questions by writing full sentences. If I ask you to discuss an issue, please consider
at least two different views of the issue along with your evaluation of the reasoning for the two different
views. If I ask you to give your personal response to a question or to state what would be personally
meaningful or applicable to you from this material, please be sure to give a full answer rather than a short one.
Questions for The Will to Believe: Local Link to the Full Text of James' The Will to Believe
1. Define the following: hypothesis, live, option, living or dead, forced or avoidable, momentous or trivial, genuine?
2. Does James accept Pascal's wager argument? What is the wager argument?
3. Why does believing by volition seem vile?
4. What is the last sentence in section 2 which summarizes Clifford's viewpoint? What concept of rationality does
Clifford assume?
5. How does James evaluate Clifford's position?
6. How is belief in truth itself something volitional?
7. What is James's thesis in section 4?
8. How does James reject skepticism in beginning of section 5? Go on to distinguish the empiricist way and the
absolutist way of believing in truth.
9. Justify the distinction between "we must know the truth" and "we must avoid error." It may be necessary to
develop examples.
10. In scientific questions and human affairs in general, why is the stronger commandment "we must avoid error"?
11. Why do moral questions present themselves such that the stronger commandment is "we must know the
truth"?
12. What is the moral question about? (Section 9) How is the question of having moral beliefs decided?
13. What is the point of the example "Do you like me or not?" What do this and other examples similar to it prove
for James?
14. What do science, morality, and religion say? (Section 10) Why is James wise to state the religious perspective
in such a general manner?
15. How does James evaluate the religious hypothesis as an option? Discuss whether or not you agree with
James's evaluation.
Local Link to the Full Text of James' The Will to Believe for Questions Above
Additional Questions from the Link: Pragmatism: Practicality and Creativity for Questions Below
11. What does science say about the world in the analysis of James? What does morality say? What does religion
say? Give examples of each.
12. Analyze the example of a moral decision about murder from the pragmatist perspective in order to support
James's view that choosing to believe can help to create the fact (or value) believed in.
13. Analyze the example of economic matters from the pragmatist perspective in order to support James's view
that choosing to believe can help to create the fact (or value) believed in.
14. Analyze the example of a woman declaring her love for a man from the pragmatist perspective in order to
support James's view that choosing to believe can help to create the fact (or value) believed in.
15. Is religious truth created or discovered for James? Explain.
Additional Questions from the Link: Some Additional Material from Varieties of Religious Experience from the material at the end of my lecture on The Will to Believe for Questions Below
8. For the material added from Varieties of Religious Experience: how does James evaluate mystical experiences?
9. Develop examples of the five characteristics of religion from your own life or that of someone whom you know.
10. What is James' statement of the religious hypothesis in Varieties of Religious Experience? Is this
psychologically real in your life? Explain. See link to Its simplest terms are an uneasiness and a deliverance;
description of the deliverances to find out why James believes that there is more than psychological truth to this
religious hypothesis. Is James' statement of the religious hypothesis objectively real in your understanding?
Explain.