ENG302 -- Topic: Semantics and Pragmatics - Assignment 8 James Madison University |
Instructions: [Your answers to this assignment should be written out clearly (or typed :) ). As an "ungraded" assignment, your work will be collected but will be marked only as an acceptable or unacceptable effort.]
A mouse has invaded my house. It has been nibbling at the bread in my kitchen. I am thinking of inviting a cat that belongs to a friend of mine to come visit me for awhile. I have searched the internet for other measures I can take, but I have not found a way to let the mouse know that I think its behavior is rude!
"A student in my Linguistics 001 class asked me a hard questions: why doesn't "reverse sarcasm" work?
We can use any positively evaluated word to mean its opposite, given a halfway appropriate context and performance: "how wonderful!", "how delicious!"
But the opposite direction rarely works: "how horrible!", "how disgusting!"
There are specific reversals, like 'bad' for 'good', but they are much more culturally, lexically, or situationally restricted.
All the obvious Gricean accounts that I can think of seem to be invertible, which is not consistent with these facts. So I did what I usually do in such cases. I asked Ellen Prince. She came back with a connection to a classic observation by Edward Sapir."